/ resources
How to Keep Control of the Customer Journey When Someone Else Handles Delivery
June 1, 2026
Content Manager, Bizrate Insights
A customer orders from your brand, has a terrible delivery experience through DoorDash or Instacart, and leaves a one-star review that tags you, not the driver. It doesn’t matter that you never touched the package after it left the warehouse. It doesn’t matter that the delay was the platform’s fault.
To that customer, you failed them.
This is the central tension of last mile delivery. Retailers have embraced third-party platforms to meet rising consumer expectations for speed and convenience, and for good reason.
The economics make sense. The infrastructure already exists. But outsourcing the delivery does not outsource the relationship.
When something goes wrong in the last mile, the blame lands on the brand, not the driver.
The retailers who understand this are treating the last mile delivery experience as an owned touchpoint, not a handed-off problem. They’re building feedback loops, setting standards that their partners are expected to meet, and measuring the post-delivery experience with the same rigor they bring to conversion and cart abandonment.
This guide is for brands that want to be in that group.
Not long ago, same-day delivery was a competitive advantage. A handful of well-resourced retailers offered it, customers were pleasantly surprised when it worked, and everyone else watched from the sidelines. That window has closed.
Same-day and local delivery have become baseline expectations across categories that have nothing to do with groceries.
Beauty brands are delivering skincare in under an hour. Pet retailers are competing with DoorDash. Home improvement chains are partnering with on-demand platforms. The global same-day delivery market was valued at $14.4 billion in 2024 and is projected to reach $36.2 billion by 2030, a compound annual growth rate of 16.6% (Global Industry Analysts, 2025). We’re witnessing a fundamental shift in how customers expect commerce to work.
For retailers, the shift is not just operational. It is experiential. Last mile delivery is now part of the brand promise. If the delivery is late, confusing, damaged, or poorly communicated, the customer does not separate that experience from the rest of the purchase journey.
Consumers want fast delivery, but they are also attentive to performance. McKinsey’s 2025 research found that delivery speed dropped from the number one consumer priority in 2022 to number five by 2024. What rose in its place? On-time reliability, accurate estimates, and proactive communication when something changes.
A customer who gets their order two hours late with no update is angrier than one who was told upfront it would take four hours and got exactly that.
The promise matters as much as the pace.
What’s also shifted is the operational complexity behind the promise. Most retailers offering same-day delivery aren’t running their own fleets. They’re piggybacking on gig economy platforms like DoorDash, Instacart, and Uber Eats. That’s a rational business decision, but it creates a new problem: more touchpoints outside your direct control at the exact moment customers are most emotionally invested in the transaction.
When a customer places an order, they’re not thinking about your carrier contract or which third-party driver picked up the package. They made a decision to trust your brand with their money and their time, and from that moment forward, everything that happens, whether owned or outsourced, is seen as your brand’s responsibility.
This is worth stating plainly, because it’s easy for retailers to think of delivery as a separate phase that begins when the order leaves their control. Remember that customers don’t see it that way.
From the moment they begin browsing your website, through delivery, is a single transaction—and their satisfaction with your brand is dependent on the entire process going smoothly.
Understanding why customers choose same-day delivery helps clarify what they actually need from the experience. Some shoppers are in emergency mode: a last-minute gift, a missing ingredient, a replacement they needed yesterday. Others are treating themselves, choosing the convenience of now over the savings of waiting. Some are filling gaps between bigger stock-up trips. And some are simply avoiding the trip altogether.
Each use case carries a different emotional weight and tolerance for failure. The shopper who needed something urgently and didn’t get it on time is angrier than the one who treated themselves and had to wait an extra hour. Insight into your customers’ motivation gives you a clearer picture of what “good” actually looks like for them and what matters most.
Regardless of use case, customers are remarkably consistent in what they prioritize when evaluating a delivery experience.
Delivery experience criteria include:
What makes this complicated is the blame question. When a third-party delivery goes wrong, who does the customer hold responsible? The data is unambiguous.
UPS Capital found in 2025 that only 39% of consumers now blame shipping providers when deliveries go wrong, down from 83% just three years earlier. Bringg’s 2026 report corroborates this: 62% of consumers hold the retailer fully or jointly responsible when deliveries go wrong, regardless of who actually handled the last mile.
The shift is significant. Customers have become sophisticated enough to know that the retailer chose the delivery partner, set the delivery promise, and took their money. In their minds, the accountability flows upward to the brand. The driver is just the last face they saw.
Here’s a question most retailers can’t answer with any confidence: how satisfied are your customers with your same-day delivery experience, specifically, compared to standard shipping? Not your overall shipping CSAT score, but explicitly for same-day deliveries, isolated and tracked over time.
If you don’t have that data yet, you’re not alone. It’s a blind spot for most retailers, especially those just getting started with last-mile delivery. But you’re also not seeing the problem clearly enough to fix it.
Most retailers measure post-delivery satisfaction in aggregate. One survey, one set of metrics, all fulfillment types lumped together. A customer who ordered standard ground and got their package in three days is answering the same questions as a customer who paid for two-hour local delivery and had it arrive an hour late. Their expectations were completely different, but the data treats them as one population.
This is how problems hide in plain sight. A 4.2 average satisfaction score looks fine. What it might actually be masking is a 4.6 for standard shipping and a 3.4 for same-day. If same-day is where you’re investing and where your most valuable customers are migrating, that’s a critical red flag you can’t see from the dashboard.
The threshold for failure is different too. A standard shipping delay is annoying, but understandable since consumers have dealt with it for years. When a customer opts for a premium service like same-day delivery, the emotional stakes climb with the price.
The scale of the underlying problem is larger than most retailers realize. Narvar’s 2025 research found that 74% of consumers experienced a late delivery in the past year. Three-quarters of your customers dealt with a late delivery last year. That’s the baseline.
That same research uncovered something else: two-thirds of consumers feel a surge of anxiety after clicking “buy.” The post-purchase window is a stretch of active anxiety. Customers are wondering whether they made the right call, and every signal they get—a tracking update, a delay notification, or silence—is shaping their impression of your brand.
The stakes are even higher with younger shoppers. That same Narvar research found that 60% of 18–29-year-olds say they won’t return to a retailer after a single bad delivery experience, compared to just 17% of shoppers 60 and older.
The influence of delivery on purchase behavior starts well before checkout, too. Narvar found that 73% of shoppers say estimated delivery dates directly influence their purchase decisions, and 40% won’t buy at all if no delivery date is shown. If your product pages and checkout flow aren’t surfacing clear delivery information, you’re losing sales before they happen.
The instinct, when something goes wrong with a third-party delivery, is to pass the blame.
“It wasn’t us! It was the driver!”
That instinct is understandable, and it’s also a fast way to lose customers. A customer decided to give you their business. Whether it was your staff or a third party delivering their goods, it is your responsibility to make it right—even when that means taking accountability for something out of your control.
The retailers who maintain ownership of the customer journey when the last mile is outsourced aren’t doing anything magical. They’re treating the parts of the experience they still control with the same rigor they’d apply to their own fleet, and they’re building accountability into their partnerships rather than hoping their platform partners will do it for them.
When a delivery goes sideways, customers don’t want to hear about it through a tracking page that hasn’t updated in six hours. They want you to tell them. Narvar’s 2025 research found that when issues arise, shoppers want proactive acknowledgment (46%), clear explanations (46%), and real-time updates (45%) before they have to ask.
That last phrase is the important one. The moment a customer has to initiate contact with your support team to figure out where their order is, you’ve already lost ground. You’ve forced them to do work to get information you could have given them proactively.
The good news is that communication is largely within your control, even when the last mile delivery isn’t. Your integration with third-party platforms will determine how much real-time visibility you can surface, but the cadence, language, and escalation decisions are yours.
Beyond problem moments, customers want visibility throughout the delivery process. Sifted’s 2025 research found that 63% of consumers consider full visibility throughout delivery “essential.” Only 4.8% said they don’t notice or care about tracking, and fewer than one in twenty shoppers are indifferent. For everyone else, it’s a key part of the experience, and the quality of it is being judged.
DispatchTrack’s research reinforces the point: 90% of consumers want order tracking capability, and 80% want proactive status updates. But that expectation has outpaced industry-wide execution with only 28% reporting they could see their delivery truck location in real time on their most recent order.
The retailers who close that gap, whether through better integration with platform partners or by layering their own communication on top of the platform’s tracking, are going to differentiate on something customers are actively evaluating.
Most conversations about same-day delivery focus on the acquisition side of the equation. Faster delivery attracts customers. Faster delivery converts carts. Faster delivery wins the comparison shop.
All of that is true. But the true ROI of last mile delivery comes from retention and lifetime value. About 76% of shoppers said a positive delivery experience influenced their decision to repurchase from a brand. Bringg’s research goes further, finding that 65% of regular shoppers said a positive delivery experience convinced them to buy again even when the price was higher than a competitor’s.
In other words, delivery quality is creating pricing power. In a competitive environment where most brands are racing to the bottom on price, that’s an enormous lever.
Same-day delivery earns loyalty, but it also raises expectations. The customers who use it most are your highest-frequency buyers, and they’ve developed a clear sense of what a good experience looks like. When you fall short, the disappointment hits harder because they have high expectations from positive past experiences with you, so the bar is higher.
Bringg found that 50% of shoppers stopped buying from a brand after a single negative delivery experience. Among high-frequency buyers, your most valuable customers by lifetime value, that number rises to 55%. The more a customer has invested in your brand, the less patience they have when it lets them down.
That’s the real cost of last-mile failure: it hits hardest where you can least afford it.
The question of how to offer local delivery, and to whom, deserves more strategic thought than it usually gets. Offering same-day as a paid option on every order treats it as a transaction. Positioning it as a loyalty perk rewards the shoppers who are already valuable to you and turns local delivery into a retention tool. A subscription model, like Sephora’s Same-Day Unlimited, front-loads customer commitment and creates a psychological contract. Seasonal or promotional offers can drive short-term lift but don’t build repeatable behavior.
None of these approaches is universally right. This should be a strategic decision made with a great deal of thought that goes beyond operational logistics.
The brands winning on last-mile delivery aren’t the ones that offered it first. It’s the companies that are committed to owning every handoff, whether it’s fully in their control or not.
The retailers getting ahead in 2026 are the ones treating last-mile delivery as a brand experience, not a logistics line item.
To join the brands leading the last mile delivery experience:
The expectations aren’t going back down. Consumers who’ve experienced reliable same-day delivery from one brand are carrying that expectation to every other brand they shop with. The retailers who build the feedback loops and accountability structures now will have a structural advantage that will be very hard for competitors to close later.
The question isn’t whether you’ll offer same-day or local delivery. Most retailers already are, or soon will be. The question is whether you’ll own the full customer experience or just outsource it and hope.
For a PDF download version of the scorecard: Download Now
Bizrate Insights helps retailers capture authentic customer feedback across the entire shopper journey, from discovery through post-delivery. Our post-delivery surveys, real-time feedback alerts, and NPS tracking by fulfillment type give ecommerce and CX teams the visibility they need to own the last-mile experience, even when they’ve outsourced the delivery.
See how Bizrate Insights can work for you at bizrateinsights.com/demo.
Introduction A customer orders from your brand, has a terrible delivery experience through DoorDash or Instacart, and leaves a...
Transcript from a presentation at SubSummit, May 2026. Cheryl Zajac, VP of Client Insights at Bizrate Insights, in conversation...
Updated 5/13/2026 For a PDF downloadable version of this report: Download Now AI is becoming a bigger part of...
